17 December 2006
Merryn Somerset-Webb, The Sunday Times - Money section
I spent last week in Berlin. Now I think I might like to move there
full-time. The city is packed full of good restaurants and bars,
fantastic modern architecture and every kind of shop you could possibly
want (including more than 50 Christmas markets this month). The
people are unusually charming; the bus and metro systems are fast,
efficient and cheap; there are few traffic jams; and best of all,
if I moved to Berlin I could actually afford to buy a proper house
to live in. |
| |
|
While house
prices have been rising beyond reason in most of Europe for the
past decade, they have barely budged in Germany. You can buy a flat
in Berlin for not far off a tenth of what it would cost in London.
There are several reasons for this — the country’s economic
difficulties and a very conservative mortgage-lending system, for
example, but the main reason seems to be that for many years it
has been cheaper to rent than buy in much of Germany. And when it
is cheaper to rent, rational people rent. |
I
met a woman in Berlin who lived only a few minutes from the Kurfustendamm,
Berlin’s main shopping street. Her flat is about 80 square
metres. Her rent is €350 euros (£235) a month and €100
of that goes on her heating and electricity. The flat’s market
price would be about €100,000, so even a very cheap interest-only
mortgage at 5% would cost her significantly more than her basic
rent (at €416 a month). Add on €100 for heating and so
on, and to buy the same kind of flat as she is renting would cost
her an extra €166 a month. Why, she asked, would she want to
do that when prices haven’t moved for 10 years? It’s
a sentiment many of her countrymen share. Across Germany only 40%
of people own the homes they live in and in Berlin a mere 13% do.
There is an often-repeated view that Germans don’t own property
for “cultural” reasons. I don’t buy it: my guess
is they don’t own property because it hasn’t made any
sense to do so. If they thought buying houses was a sure-fire way
to get rich, they would buy houses.
The interesting thing here is that I am beginning to suspect that
it might be a sure-fire way to get rich. Why? Because the cost balance
between renting and buying is slowly shifting and that means demand
is going to rise. The main reason rents are so low in much of Germany
is because a large amount of the housing stock is government-owned,
and the government likes rents to be low. In Berlin, I am told,
the state doesn’t like to charge anyone more than €5
a square metre a month. The highest average rents in the country
are charged in Munich, where you can expect to pay around €12
a square metre. That means that the most you can pay for a 100 square
metre apartment is €1,200 euros a month, about the amount you’d
pay per week in central London.
However, this tenant-friendly situation isn’t going to last
much longer. The government cannot continue to subsidise housing
because it is heavily in debt, so it has begun to sell off much
of its housing assets to large private investors. These firms, mainly
UK and US-based, have bought up $25 billion (£13 billion)
of formerly state owned German property, and in March the mayor
of Dresden sold his city’s entire stock — 48,000 apartments
— to Fortress Investment, a US private-equity group, wiping
out its entire public debt.
Fortress and the other new owners of Germany’s houses are
unlikely to manage their new holdings in quite so charitable a way.
The result? Rents are going to rise and that’s going to make
owning look more attractive than it has for a long time.
The other part of the equation is the mortgage market. Even if you
had wanted to buy a house in Berlin five years ago, you wouldn’t
have been able to unless you’d had substantial savings: the
banks made you put down huge deposits and then charged very high
interest rates.
But that is now changing too. As a real single market in financial
products spreads across Europe the German banks are having to offer
a bit more: you can now get competitive interest rates and even
100% mortgages if that’s what you want, all things that bring
down the cost of buying.
The big buyers of Berlin’s residential blocks make their returns
not just from notching up rents, but by knocking on doors with a
mortgage adviser by their side and asking their tenants if they
want to buy them out. An increasing number of people are doing the
sums and saying yes, which I think is probably the right answer:
when buying is cheaper than renting, rational people buy.
Finally it is worth noting that the German economy is making a strong-looking
recovery. After growing a pathetic 1.2% between early 2001 and 2005,
the economy has suddenly woken up: in the third quarter GDP grew
at an annualised rate of nearly 3%. The jobless figures have fallen
by 500,000 in the past year to under 4m. Business confidence is
at a 15-year high and even Germany’s consumers seem to have
a bit of Christmas spirit going: consumer confidence is at a five-year
high. All this also bodes well for the property market.
The bad news is that it isn’t easy for individual investors
to buy in Germany. The market is still illiquid and quite opaque
— it can be hard to know what real market prices are. Commissions,
charges and taxes on transactions are high, so buying just one flat
has long been just too difficult. |